Dating again after a long relationship is often described as frightening, complicated and emotionally exhausting…
Why Do We Keep Having the Same Argument?
Summary
This episode explores the patterns behind recurring arguments in relationships, revealing how understanding these patterns can lead to healthier communication and connection.
Key Topics
The analogy of warning lights in trucks and recurring arguments in relationships
The importance of understanding what keeps creating arguments
The loop of message, meaning, and response in conflicts
The pursuit and withdrawal pattern in relationships
The distinction between fault and impact in behaviour
How stories and beliefs shape our reactions
Strategies to observe and interrupt patterns
The role of curiosity and different responses in change
Takeaways
Recurring arguments often mask underlying emotional patterns.
Understanding what keeps happening between partners is more useful than focusing on the subject.
Changing responses can break the cycle, even if the other person doesn’t change.
Recognising patterns is difficult because our own behaviour makes sense to us.
Progress involves noticing patterns sooner and choosing different responses.
Chapters
00:00 Introduction to recurring relationship patterns
00:25 The analogy of recurring arguments and warning lights
01:01 Why becoming better at ending arguments isn’t enough
02:01 Common subjects of conflict and their underlying patterns
03:08 Different underlying experiences behind similar arguments
04:13 The loop of message, meaning, and response in conflicts
05:37 Perspective of both partners in a recurring pattern
07:03 The pursuit and withdrawal pattern explained
09:31 Criticise and defend cycle in relationships
10:25 Fault versus impact in behavior
11:07 Taking responsibility without blame
14:37 How to observe and interrupt patterns
16:00 Trying something different to break the cycle
18:04 Recognising patterns and the importance of curiosity
19:26 Questions to ask to understand and change patterns
20:17 Conclusion and encouragement to explore patterns
Transcript
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (00:05.56)
G’day and welcome to another episode of Relationship Revolutions. Have you ever finished an argument with your partner and thought, hang on a minute. We’ve had this conversation before. Maybe it was about something completely different last time. Today is the washing up. Last time it was money. Before that, it was your phone. Different subject.
Different day, but strangely a very familiar argument.
The same frustration, the same defensiveness, the same person withdrawing, the same person getting louder, and quite often the same ending.
So today I want to explore why we can keep having what feels like the same argument over and over again. Even when we think we’re arguing about completely different things. Because maybe the subject keeps changing, but the pattern does not.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (01:23.532)
Before I became the love engineer, I spent years working on trucks. And there’s parti something particularly frustrating about a recurring fault. A truck comes into the workshop, the warning lights on, you deal with it. The truck goes out. Two weeks later, it’s back. The same warning light, so you deal with it again. And it goes off. And then it’s back. Eventually.
You’ve got stop congratulating yourself for becoming incredibly efficient at turning the warning light off and ask a better question.
Why does this keep happening?
Because that warning light isn’t necessarily the problem. It’s telling you that there is a problem.
And I think recurring arguments can be a little bit like that.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (02:20.896)
If you keep having the same disagreement, perhaps becoming better at ending the argument isn’t enough. Maybe it’s worth understanding what keeps creating these arguments.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (02:39.8)
Think about some of the things couples argue about money, housework, sex, phones, being late, children, family, going out with friends how much time you spend together.
How much time you spend apart, all completely legitimate subjects. And I want to be clear about that.
If something if someone isn’t doing their share around the house, that can be a real problem. If someone keeps spending money you’ve agreed not to spend, that’s a real problem. If intimacy is disp disappeared from the relationship, that’s definitely worth talking about.
So we’re not dismissing the subject.
But sometimes several apparently unrelated disagreements have something remarkably similar sitting underneath them.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (03:50.072)
The washing up becomes I don’t feel appreciated. Being late becomes I can’t rely on you. The phone becomes I don’t feel important.
And a conversation about money becomes I don’t feel safe. A rest bec a request becomes nothing I do is ever good enough. A question becomes you’re trying to control me. Different subjects, same underlying experience. And suddenly the dishwasher is carrying the emotional weight of a small family hatchback.
So perhaps instead of asking why do que we keep arguing about the dishwasher or whatever the argument appears to be about there’s another question worth asking What keeps happening between us?
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (04:56.344)
Let’s take something incredibly ordinary. You message your partner, they don’t reply. That’s the event. Now if you’ve listened to the previous episode, you’ll remember we talked about something like this event, meaning, response, and outcome. Something happens, we give it a meaning. That meaning influences how we respond.
And our response contributes to what happens next. But here’s where it gets particularly interesting. Because that outcome can never become the next event. Because that outcome can become the next event. And now we have a loop. So your message your partner, there’s no reply.
You think I’m obviously not important enough for them to reply. You send another message still nothing. Now you’re feeling anxious or frustrated.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (06:13.272)
So you send Nice to know I’m such a priority.
Your partner eventually looks at their phone. They’ve been busy. They see three messages. And the sar then the sarcastic one. What happens in their head?
Maybe for God’s sake here we go again Or nothing I do is ever enough Or I just don’t have the energy for this right now So they decide they’ll reply later What happens to you? More silence
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (06:57.122)
And your phone shows the messages have been read. And what does that silence appear to prove? See? I knew they didn’t care. So perhaps you send another message or become colder.
or despair decide that you’re not speaking to them when they get home. And around we go.
Now let’s look at it from the other side. This is where relationship patterns become fascinating.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (07:36.642)
Because let’s tell exactly the same story from the other person’s perspective. They’re working, they’re busy, their phone somewhere else. Eventually they pick it up. There’s several messages.
And the last one says, nice to know that I’m such a priority. And they think, for God’s sake, I can’t even get through a meeting without this happening. Maybe maybe their experience is whatever I do is not good enough. So they withdraw. Not necessarily because they don’t care, maybe they’re trying to avoid an argument.
Maybe they’re trying to regulate themselves before replying. Maybe they genuinely do not know what to say.
But their withdrawal lands on the other person’s I don’t matter. And now we have two people doing things that make complete sense from inside their own experience, while simultaneously making the other person’s experience worse.
Nobody got out of bed that morning and thought.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (09:00.898)
You know what this relationship needs? A really unhealthy dynamic before lunch. They’re reacting to each other.
And each person’s solution is becoming part of the other’s problem.
Just before we go any further.
If you’re enjoying these conversations and they’re helping relationships just make a little more sense, make sure you follow and subscribe to Relationship Revolutions. And if you got thirty seconds, please leave a five star review. I’d really appreciate it and it helps more people discover the podcast.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (09:52.546)
The pursue and the withdrawal This is one of the easiest patterns to recognise. One person senses distance, so they move towards the other person. They ask questions What is wrong? Are you okay? Why aren’t you talking to me? Have I done something wrong?
Maybe they send another message. Maybe they want to resolve things immediately. They’re trying to create connection. But the other person experiences that movement towards them as pressure. So they move away, they go quiet, they ask for space. Maybe physically leave the room. What does that first person experience?
Even more distance So they move closer Why are you walking away? Can we please just sort this out? Talk to me which creates more pressure. So the other person moves further away. Can you see the loop?
Distance creates pursuit and pursuit creates pressure. Pressure creates distance and around we go. Now here’s what’s particularly interesting. Both people may actually care deeply about the relationship. The person pursuing may be thinking we need to talk about this because I don’t want us to drift apart.
The other person might be withdrawing. If I stay in this conversation right now, I’m going to say something I’ll regret. I need some space.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (11:46.818)
Maybe both are trying to protect something without understanding the pattern. Each person’s behavior looks like proof of the other’s worst interpretation.
Criticize and defend another common one. One person says You never listen to me. What happens? Defense. That’s because all you ever do is criticize me. Now the first person feels even less hurt.
I’m criticizing you because you never listen to me. And the other person says, And this is why I don’t talk to you. And around we go. Criticism, defense, more criticism, more defense. And the fascinating part is each person’s behaviour makes sense to them. If I’m not being heard, I might speak louder.
If I am being unfairly attacked, I might defend myself, but what happens next?
My louder criticism makes you feel more attacked. The stronger your defense makes me feel less heard. So I criticize harder and you defend harder. Eventually, neither of us is actually discussing whatever started the conversation. We are simply reacting to each other’s reactions.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (13:28.76)
Fault versus impact This is where I think we need to make an important distinction.
Understanding your part in a pattern does not mean accepting responsibility for everything the other person does. It doesn’t mean well if I’d communicated perfectly, they wouldn’t have behaved badly. No. People are responsible for their own behaviour.
And someone’s behaviour genuinely is acceptable.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (14:09.824)
And sometimes someone’s behaviour genuinely is unacceptable. But there’s a useful question we can ask ourselves without taking responsibility for the whole relationship.
And that is what tends to happen next when I do what I normally do. That’s different from whose fault is this?
Let’s say my normal response when I’m hurt is to go silent. Maybe I have very good reasons for doing that. But what impact does my silence have? Perhaps my partner becomes anxious. So they start asking more questions. That feels intrusive, so I withdraw further, and again, I don’t have to blame myself. I can simply notice.
When I do this, this tends to happen next. That’s information. And once we’ve got information, we have choices.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (15:22.38)
Why patterns are so difficult to see?
I think there’s a simple reason recurring patterns can be incredibly difficult to ri recognise. Our own behavior makes sense to us. Of course it does. We’re experiencing everything that came before it. If I believe you are ignoring me, my pursuit makes sense. If I believe you are attacking me, my defence makes sense.
If I believe conflict isn’t safe, walking away makes sense. If I believe you’re trying to control me, resisting makes sense. From inside our own experience, we don’t necessarily see ourselves as part of a pattern.
We see ourselves as responding to what the other person is doing.
And we’re incredibly good at spotting their behavior. That’s because it’s happening to us. We see their withdrawal or their criticism or their defensiveness or their questions, their sarcasm. We don’t always see as clearly what happened immediately before it. And what we did immediately before that.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (16:59.384)
We start collecting evidence. There’s something else that can happen. Once we’ve developed a story about someone.
We become remarkably good at finding evidence to back it up. If my story is they don’t care about me, I’ll notice the unanswered message. I’ll notice when they’re distracted. I’ll notice when they forget something. I may par pay rather less attention to the cup of tea they’ve just made me.
Thing they remembered from a conversation three weeks ago.
or the fact they rearranged their day when I needed help.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (17:54.316)
Likewise if my story is nothing I do is ever good enough, I’ll become incredibly sensitive to criticism. A simple request can start sounding like an axe accusation. Could you put that away? Because here we go again another thing I’ve done wrong.
And now I respond to the accusation that I heard, rather than the request that is actually made. And this doesn’t mean our stories are always wrong. Sometimes there’s plenty of evidence for them. But it’s worth becoming curious about whether we are gathering information or simply collecting evidence for a conclusion we’ve already reached.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (18:50.442)
So how do you interrupt the pattern?
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (18:56.728)
This is normally the point where a podcast would give you five simple steps to never argue again. But I’m not going to do that. Because relationships aren’t that simple. Instead, what I’d like to give you is something to observe. Next time, one of those strangely familiar disagreements
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (19:25.954)
Perhaps don’t start with how do we stop this? Start with what is actually happening?
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (19:36.674)
And when things have calmed down a little, walk yourself through it. What happened? What was the event? And then what did I decide that it meant? Maybe I’m not important. I’m being criticized. They’re trying to control me. They don’t care. And then what did I do next? Did I pursue? Did I withdraw? Did I criticize everything?
Or did I defend? Did I become sarcastic or try to fix it?
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (20:21.356)
And then what did they do in response? And then
What did their response make me want to do next?
Because that’s where the pattern starts becoming visible. Not who’s the bad guy.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (20:43.838)
Not who started it, just what keeps happening between us.
Do something different.
And once you can see that sequence is the really interesting question. Where could I do something different? Notice I didn’t say better, just different.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (21:13.9)
Because if you always do A and A is followed by B which leads to C
And then brings you back to A. What happens if you change one part of that sequence? Maybe instead of sending another message, you pause. Instead of assuming, you ask.
Maybe instead of saying you never listen to me, you say I don’t feel heard right now.
Maybe instead of d defending you become curious.
Maybe instead of immediately trying to fix your partner’s problem, you listen. Maybe instead of disappearing for two days, you say, I need twenty minutes to calm down, but I promise I’ll come back and we will finish this conversation. It’s a small difference, but potentially very different information. And I want to be clear here.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (22:21.558)
Changing your response does not guarantee the other person will change theirs. Relationships involve two people.
You cannot control the other half of the pattern, but you can interrupt the automatic sequence. When you do something different, you discover something. Maybe your partner responds differently too, maybe they don’t.
Both outcomes give you information.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (22:59.586)
The goal isn’t to never repeat a pattern.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (23:06.51)
There’s one more thing I think is worth saying. Recognizing a pattern does not mean you will never fall into it again. You probably will. Especially when you’re tired or stressed or scared or under pressure. The aim is not perfection here. Sometimes progress looks a little like recognizing the pattern sooner. At first you’ll notice it three days later.
we did that thing again.
Then maybe you notice an hour later, then halfway through the argument, and eventually perhaps you catch yourself just as you’re about to send that message, or make that sarcastic comment, or shut the conversation down and you think, here we go. That moment matters. Because now you have a choice.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (24:07.69)
So why do we keep having the same argument? Perhaps sometimes we aren’t. Maybe we’re having lots of different arguments, but if the emotions are same and the interpretations and the same responses
and the same outcomes keep appearing, then perhaps there’s a pattern with understanding.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (24:36.738)
When I was fixing trucks, if the same warning light kept coming back on.
I wouldn’t congratulate myself for becoming a really efficient at resetting the warning light.
I want to know why does this thing keep coming on?
And maybe there’s something useful for relationships too. If you keep having what feels like the same arguments, perhaps the question isn’t simply how do we stop arguing about this? Perhaps it is what keeps happening between us? What happens? What do I decide it means? What do I do next? What do they do?
And what happens after that? Because once you can see the pattern, you’ve got something you can actually work with. And perhaps the question I’d leave you with this week is where in our familiar pattern could I try doing something different? Not to manipulate the other person into changing. Not because everything is your fault.
Alan Watts – The Love Engineer (25:55.03)
Simply because curiosity gives you information.
And that information gives you choices.
So if today’s conversation has helped one little thing make a little more sense, then we’ve achieved exactly what relationship revolutions is here to do. And if someone came to mind while you were listening today, perhaps send them this episode. It might help something make a little more sense for them too.
So until next time, take care of yourself and each other.

Comments (0)